S is usually the top group
Many tier lists place S above A. The letters are labels, not a standard measurement system. Define S in terms of the question you are answering: your favorite, your most reliable option or your first priority.
Tiers group similar judgments
A can mean a strong choice, B a useful choice with trade-offs, C a narrower fit and D an option you would rarely choose for the task. The exact meanings are yours to define. Two items in the same tier do not need to be ordered unless you say so.
Unknown is different from bad
An item you have not tried belongs in Unranked. Putting it in D suggests a negative judgment you may not have evidence for. Keep unfamiliar items separate and revisit them later.
Use labels that fit the task
For a project board, “Do now,” “Next,” “Later” and “Not enough information” may be clearer than letter grades. For a game board, separate roles or modes before assigning a single overall rank.